Italian Game: Two Knights Defense, Polerio Defense

Popularity increased 26% since 2013

C581.e4 e5 2.Nf3 Nc6 3.Bc4 Nf6 4.Ng5 d5 5.exd5 Na5

Feb 20, 20264 min read

TL;DR The respected reply to 4.Ng5: Black ignores recapturing on d5 and hits the c4-bishop to drag it off the dangerous diagonal. The bishop pair and queenside files compensate for the pawn, and Black scores 49.6% — a rare advantage for the defender.

Italian Game: Two Knights Defense, Polerio Defense: A Complete Guide
Italian Game: Two Knights Defense, Polerio Defense - Opening Moves

Summary

Starting from 1.e4 e5 2.Nf3 Nc6 3.Bc4 Nf6 4.Ng5 d5 5.exd5 Na5, players enter the Italian Game: Two Knights Defense, Polerio Defense — ECO C58. The knight goes to the rim, the bishop is forced to retreat, and Black is happy to be a pawn down. This is the Polerio, the modern main line for surviving Ng5 and getting active play in return.

Strategic Overview

5...Na5 is Black's most respected answer to the Ng5 attack. Instead of meekly recapturing on d5 and inviting the Fried Liver, Black ignores the pawn, hits the c4-bishop, and forces White to make a concrete decision about where it goes. The bishop usually drops back to b5 with check, and after a long forcing sequence Black ends up with the bishop pair, open queenside files, and very active piece play in exchange for the gambited pawn. White's structure is fine but the development lead is gone and the king on e1 isn't where it wants to be. The middlegame plays itself around Black's lead in mobilisation and the weakness of White's queenside light squares. Anyone playing the Two Knights with Black needs to know this line cold, because it's the difference between equality with chances and being a sad pawn down for nothing. Theory is deep but the moves make sense: chase the bishop, get the pieces out, and pile pressure on White's king before they consolidate the extra pawn.

Key Ideas

When players succeed in this line, they usually do so by leaning on the following themes:

  • The knight attacks the bishop, not the centre — 5...Na5 looks anti-positional because the knight heads to the edge, but its job is to harass the c4-bishop and disrupt White's coordination. The pawn deficit is temporary compensation; the development lead is the point.
  • Black plays for activity, not material — Black is comfortable staying a pawn down for several moves while finishing development. White's extra pawn on d5 is hard to defend long-term, and Black's bishop pair plus open lines usually balance the material.
  • White's king is the long-term weakness — After the bishop dance, White often has to delay castling and resort to awkward moves like Bd3. Black's pressure on the e-file and the diagonal toward h1 keeps the initiative alive even when the position looks calm.

History and Notable Players

It arises from the Italian Game: Two Knights Defense, Knight Attack. Among the most prolific White practitioners are Enrico Paoli (22 games), Hagen Poetsch (16 games), Nigel D Short (12 games). Black-side regulars include Mikhail Chigorin (11 games), Arthur Bernard Bisguier (10 games), Alexander G Beliavsky (10 games).

Main Lines and Variations

The main branches off 1.e4 e5 2.Nf3 Nc6 3.Bc4 Nf6 4.Ng5 d5 5.exd5 Na5 include:

Each branch leads to a different middlegame character — the resulting pawn structure decides what kind of game you get.

Common Mistakes

  • Drifting away from main theory — At 400 Elo, the three most-played moves cover 69.1% of games, against 98.1% at 2000. The most popular deviation is Bb3 (played 11.5% of the time at 400, much less so up top). It looks fine but quietly hands the better-prepared side an edge.
  • Neglecting development — It can feel productive to make extra pawn moves early, but falling behind in piece development is what loses most amateur games — especially in open positions where active pieces find squares fast.
  • Playing without a plan — Each Italian Game: Two Knights Defense, Polerio Defense middlegame demands a specific approach. Decide whether the position calls for attack, manoeuvre, or simplification before reaching for a move.

Practice on Chessiverse

Ready to try the Italian Game: Two Knights Defense, Polerio Defense against a bot? Pick an opponent at your level and play a game.

Play the Italian Game: Two Knights Defense, Polerio Defense

Play As
Start From

After 1.e4 e5 2.Nf3 Nc6 3.Bc4 Nf6 4.Ng5 d5 5.exd5 Na5 Pick the position up and play on from there.

Opponent

No account needed — your game saves if you sign up after.

Want the full game experience — enter the game arena!

Quick Facts

Games on Lichess
7,502,180
Most Popular At
1600
Sharpness
Sharp
Scored as part of the Two Knights family
Main Line
1.e4 e5 2.Nf3 Nc6 3.Bc4 Nf6 4.Ng5 d5 5.exd5 Na5
FEN
r1bqkb1r/ppp2ppp/5n2/n2Pp1N1/2B5/8/PPPP1PPP/RNBQK2R w KQkq - 1 6
Style
Romantic

White wins 46.7%, draws 3.6%, Black wins 49.6%.

Top Players

Data from Lichess opening explorer (blitz & rapid)

Romantic
Romantic openings prioritize piece activity, open lines, and direct attacks on the king over material considerations. They echo the swashbuckling style of 19th-century chess masters.

Popularity by Rating

Popularity view

It's played most at 1600: about 1 in 530 games there, against 1 in 2,700 games at 400. At 1200, White wins 46% and Black 51%; at 2500 it's 49% to 44%, with more draws (7%).

Percentage of all games at each rating bracket that feature this opening.

Data from Lichess opening explorer (blitz & rapid games)

Theory Adherence by Rating

Theory adherence view

At 1200, White's most common reply is 6.Bb5+ (60% of games), with three other moves each played in at least 1 in 20 games. By 2500 it comes down to two: 6.Bb5+ (90%) and 6.d3 (10%).

How often players choose the single most popular move at this position. Higher = more predictable play.

White to move after the opening line

Popularity Over Time

It's more popular than it used to be: about 1 in 650 games in 2025, up from 1 in 820 games in 2013. It peaked in 2017, at 1 in 570 games.

Share of all Lichess blitz + rapid games featuring this opening, by year.

Top Moves by Rating

White to move after the opening line

Top moves by rating
RatingMost Popular2nd3rd
4006.Bb5+46.1%6.Bb311.5%6.d311.4%
10006.Bb5+50%6.Bb311.9%6.d310.2%
12006.Bb5+59.5%6.Bb310.3%6.Qe29%
14006.Bb5+70.2%6.Qe27.9%6.Bb37.4%
16006.Bb5+81%6.Qe25.4%6.d34.9%
18006.Bb5+87.4%6.d35.5%6.Qe23%
20006.Bb5+89.8%6.d37.1%6.Qe21.1%
22006.Bb5+89.5%6.d39.4%6.Qe20.2%
25006.Bb5+89.5%6.d39.8%6.b30.2%

Popularity by Time Control

The slower the game, the more it's played: about 1 in 550 rapid games, against 1 in 930 bullet games. White wins more often in bullet (48%) than in rapid (45%).

  • Bullet0.11%2.9M
  • Blitz0.15%5.5M
  • Rapid0.18%2.0M

2% more decisive in bullet

Raw Data Tables (Lichess Blitz + Rapid)
Italian Game: Two Knights Defense, Polerio Defense: popularity and win rates by player rating
Rating (Elo)Share %GamesWhite win %Black win %Draw %Sharpness
4000.0484,75443.153.93.00.970
10000.09394,10244.552.53.00.970
12000.151,034,43145.551.43.10.969
14000.191,682,89646.150.63.30.967
16000.191,867,26847.149.43.50.965
18000.171,455,54847.848.33.90.961
20000.16721,39448.147.54.40.956
22000.14243,38748.246.35.40.946
25000.1318,40049.343.57.30.927
Italian Game: Two Knights Defense, Polerio Defense: move-choice theory adherence by rating
Rating (Elo)Top moveTop move %Viable movesTheory %Entropy
4006.Bb5+46.1669.12.606
10006.Bb5+50.0472.12.460
12006.Bb5+59.5478.82.121
14006.Bb5+70.2485.51.689
16006.Bb5+81.0291.21.192
18006.Bb5+87.4295.80.831
20006.Bb5+89.8298.10.636
22006.Bb5+89.5299.10.565
25006.Bb5+89.5299.60.536
Italian Game: Two Knights Defense, Polerio Defense: popularity over time
YearShare %GamesWhite win %Black win %Draw %
20130.123,50944.951.83.3
20140.1311,98643.553.33.3
20150.1634,98845.151.53.3
20160.17105,35446.050.73.4
20170.18200,30746.650.03.4
20180.17309,71146.749.83.5
20190.16448,71347.049.63.4
20200.16941,44846.349.93.8
20210.161,208,39746.649.73.7
20220.161,177,62047.049.43.5
20230.161,275,57546.849.63.6
20240.161,197,40447.049.43.6
20250.151,133,69946.749.73.6
Italian Game: Two Knights Defense, Polerio Defense: popularity by time control
FormatShare %GamesWhite win %Black win %Draw %Sharpness
bullet0.112,867,72948.049.72.30.977
blitz0.155,490,17947.449.13.50.965
rapid0.182,012,00145.051.13.90.961
Italian Game: Two Knights Defense, Polerio Defense: top candidate moves by rating bracket
Rating (Elo)1st move1st %2nd move2nd %3rd move3rd %
4006.Bb5+46.16.Bb311.56.d311.4
10006.Bb5+50.06.Bb311.96.d310.2
12006.Bb5+59.56.Bb310.36.Qe29.0
14006.Bb5+70.26.Qe27.96.Bb37.4
16006.Bb5+81.06.Qe25.46.d34.9
18006.Bb5+87.46.d35.56.Qe23.0
20006.Bb5+89.86.d37.16.Qe21.1
22006.Bb5+89.56.d39.46.Qe20.2
25006.Bb5+89.56.d39.86.b30.2
Italian Game: Two Knights Defense, Polerio Defense: top practitioners by side
SidePlayerGames
WhiteEnrico Paoli22
WhiteHagen Poetsch16
WhiteNigel D Short12
BlackMikhail Chigorin11
BlackArthur Bernard Bisguier10
BlackAlexander G Beliavsky10

Frequently Asked Questions

Italian Game: Two Knights Defense, Polerio Defense

What is this opening?

This opening begins with 1.e4 e5 2.Nf3 Nc6 3.Bc4 Nf6 4.Ng5 d5 5.exd5 Na5 and is classified under ECO code C58. This is Black's best move.

Is this opening good for beginners?

This opening can be played at any level. Beginners should focus on understanding the key strategic ideas rather than memorizing long theoretical lines. Our AI bots at various rating levels provide a great way to practice the opening concepts.

What are the main variations of this opening?

The main continuations include: this opening, Suhle Defense. Each variation leads to distinct types of positions with their own strategic themes.

What are the win rates for this opening?

In a database of 7,502,180 games, White wins 46.7% of the time, Black wins 49.6%, and 3.6% are drawn. Notable players on the White side include Enrico Paoli and Hagen Poetsch. On the Black side, Mikhail Chigorin and Arthur Bernard Bisguier are among the most frequent practitioners.

Brought to you by

IM John BartholomewCo-Founder & Chess Educator

International Master and chess educator. Co-founded Chessable and joined Chessiverse as co-founder. Best known for his "Climbing the Rating Ladder" YouTube series and structured opening courses.

Practice This Opening on Chessiverse

Play against 1000+ AI bots with unique personalities and opening repertoires. From beginner-friendly to grandmaster-level opponents, find the perfect sparring partner for any opening.

Not sure which opening fits you? Take the free chess personality test — your style determines which openings will work with you.

Back to Articles